A comparative analysis of the requirements of Russia and the United States to the fire resistance of building structures of oil refineries and petrochemical plants

Introduction. Currently, national standards and codes of practice contain deterministic values of the fire resistance of building structures of facilities of the Russian fuel and energy complex (FEC), while a probabilistic approach to determining their fire resistance is not specified in the Russian regulatory documents. The methodology of the probabilistic approach to the fire resistance of structures is detailed in API 2218 “Fireproofing Practices in Petroleum and Petrochemical Processing Plants”, developed by the American Petroleum Institute.
Methods. A comparative analysis of the Russian regulatory documents on fire safety and API 2218 in terms of the established concepts of fireproofing and requirements for the fire resistance limits of building structures of oil and gas industry facilities, is carried out.
Results. It was established that the Russian Federation has no regulatory documents establishing methods based on the probabilistic approach, including determination of the required fire resistance limits and points of application of fire-resistant coatings at facilities of the fuel and energy complex by analogy with international standard API 2218.
Conclusion. Based on the analysis, it was concluded that approaches to the philosophy of the fire resistance of structures of buildings and structures of the fuel and energy complex in the documents under consideration are fundamentally different. In order to improve the Russian regulatory and technical framework, governing fire safety and fire resistance, it is proposed to consider the requirements of foreign documents that take into account proven international engineering and technical practices, in particular, the use of a probabilistic approach taking into account hydrocarbon fires.

1. Prisadkov V.I. A realibility of building structures at a fire. Fire resistances of building structures. Moscow, VNIIPO Publ., 1986; 70-73. (rus).

2. Prisadkov V.I. A creation of methods for a choice of an optimal fire protection system for industrial buildings : dissertation of doctor of technical sciences. Moscow, 1990; 290. (rus).

3. Shebeko Yu.N., Shebeko A.Yu., Giletich A.N. About the fire safety conditions to determine the admissible parameters of industrial premises functioning. Pozharovzryvobezopasnost/Fire and Explosion Safety. 2009; 4:61-66. DOI: 10.18322/PVB.2018.27.11.51-57 (rus).

4. Shebeko A.Yu., Shebeko Yu.N., Gordienko D.M. Estimation of required fire resistance limits of bearing structures of refinery platforms and pipe racks. Pozharnaya bezopasnost/Fire Safety. 2017; 1:25-29. (rus).

5. Shebeko Yu.N., Shebeko A.Yu., Giletich A.N. About the fire safety conditions to determine the admissible parameters of industrial premises functioning. Pozharnaya bezopasnost/Fire Safety. 2018; 22(11):51-57. (rus).

6. Shebeko A.Yu. A Settlement assessment of equivalent fire duration for steel structures of pipe rack of a refinery. Pozharnaya bezopasnost/Fire Safety. 2019; 1:103-107. (rus).

7. Klementev B.A., Oleynikov S.N. The basic directions of development of standardization: ensuring the fire safety of liquefied natural gas. Modern fire-safe materials and technologies : Collection of materials of the International Scientific and Practical Conference dedicated to the Year of Safety Culture. Ivanovo, September 19, 2018. Part II. Ivanovo, 2018; 233-239. URL: https://www.elibrary.ru/item.asp?id=42307945&pff=1

8. Khasanov I.R., Gravit M.V., Kosachev A.A., Pekhotikov A.V., Pavlov V.V. Harmonization of European and Russian regulatory documents establishing general requirements for fire-resistance test methods of building constructions and the use of temperature curves that take into account real fire conditions. Pozharovzryvobezopasnost/Fire and Explosion Safety. 2014; 23(3):49-57. URL: https://www.elibrary.ru/item.asp?id=21639720

9. Drinberg A.S., Gravit M.V., Zybina О.А. Fire protection with intumescent coatings under the hydrocarbon fire conditions. Lakokrasochnie materialy i ikh primenenie/Russian Coatings Journal. 2018; 1-2:44-49.

10. Gravit M., Golub E., Klementev B., Dmitriev I. Fire protective glass fiber reinforced concrete plates for steel structures under different types of fire exposure. Buildings. 2021; 11:187. DOI: 10.3390/buildings11050187

11. Gravit M., Gumerova E., Bardin A., Lukinov V. Increase of fire resistance limits of building structures of oil-and-gas complex under hydrocarbon fire. International Scientific Conference Energy Management of Municipal Transportation Facilities and Transport EMMFT 2017. Springer, 2018; 692:818-829. DOI: 10.1007/978-3-319-70987-1_87

12. Gravit M., Zimin S., Lazarev Y., Dmitriev I., Golub E. Fire simulation of bearing structures for natural gas module plant. VIII International Scientific Siberian Transport Forum. Popovic Z., Manakov A., Breskich V. (eds). Springer, Cham., 2020; 1116: 365-376. DOI: 10.1007/978-3-030-37919-3_36

13. Gravit M.V., Golub E.V., Antonov S.P. Fire protective dry plaster composition for structures in hydrocarbon fire. Magazine of Civil Engineering. 2018; 3:86-94. DOI: 10.18720/MCE.79.9

14. Guidelines for chemical process quantitative risk analysis. 2nd. ed. AIChE/CCPS, 2000; 744.